Robert W. Gick, 1921
John B. Davis, 1922
#John P. Moscony, 1922, 1923, 1924
A. Culver Boyd, 1923
Charles A. Simons, 1924
Ralph W. Conrad, 1925
#Nicholas E. Finola, 1925, 1942
Andrew H. Dill, 1926
#Joseph Richetti, 1926
T. Edgar Beatty, 1927
#John B. Cianciarulo, 1927
Walter C. Powell, 1928
#Peter A. Cautilli, 1928
J. Norman Stephens, 1929
#Gioacchino P. Giambalvo, 1929, 1934
William C. Broughton, 1930
#Tosellidel Guercio, 1930, 1935
George A. Hansen, 1931
#Joseph T. Ramella, 1931
Robert S. Hunter, 1932
#Joseph Benevento, 1932
Walter L. Webb, 1933
#Philip T. Calabrese, 1933
E. Lewis Reiff, 1934
Dawson Dowell, 1935
Samuel Todd, 1936
#Dominic Costelluccio, 1936
Charles H. Powell, 1937
#D. Anthony Fascenda, Jr., 1937
Roy F. Kraber, 1938
#Frank Luccheiti, 1938
Norman Light, 1939
#Edward L. DiBono, 1939
William E. Schaffnit, 1940
#Frank A. Lombardo, 1940
Robert S. Hanson, 1941
#Frank J. Garramone, 1941, 1965
John H. Fetterolf, 1942
Miller E. Hutton, 1943
#Francis Mazzoni, 1943, 1952
Raymond L. Shott, 1944
#Joseph C. DiFrancesco, 1944
William H. Zane, 1945
#Romolo Mazzoni, 1945
*Charles A. Seaman, 1945
*Robert S. Gebhardt, 1945
Harry W. Schenk, 1946
#Percy Perucci, 1946
William J. MacCauley, 1947
#Peter Flandra, 1947
Edmund C. Wray, 1948
#Carl Galatino, 1948, 1953
Alexander Kerr, Jr., 1949
#Mark G. Arcuri, 1949
William E. Hannum, 1950
#Frank F. DiDonato, 1950
Raymond R. Vincent, 1951
#Joseph P. Flandra, 1951
G. Conrad Svenson, 1952
*John C. F. Kitzelman, 1952
*James A. Johnston, 1952
*Thomas E. Mowry, 1952
*Eldridge P. Miller, 1952
Sydney C. Jones, 1953
Stanley F. Thompson, 1954
#Anthony Yacovelly, Jr., 1954
Edwin E. Davey, 1955
#Jonas H. Carpenter, 1955, 1967, 1968
James F. Strong, 1956
#James L. Montgomery, 1956
Howard R. Spangler, 1957
*Edward H. Rutter, 1957
Thomas L. Shaiko, 1958
#John L. Litchfield, 1958
*Herbert N. Ammlung, 1958
John D. Springer, 1959
#Peter Giaquinto, 1959, 1960
William J. Martin, 1960
Arthur G. Miller, 1961
Paul J. Gossin, Jr., 1962
#Frank Renzetti, 1962, 1963, 1964
Robert K. Hartley, 1963
Harold C. Hartley, 1964
Gene H. Ritsert, Sr., 1965
Charles O. McCaslin, 1966
Thomas Dracup, 1967
William L. Hudson, Sr., 1968
*George W. Mumford, 1968
John H. Gamble, 1969
#Joseph H. Hones, 1969
Albert C. Menger III, 1970
#Frank W. Schmitt, 1970
Carl A. Sandberg, 1971
#William E. DiSanto, 1971
Latimer G. Myers, 1972
#John W. Albaugh, 1972
Robert T. Isaac, 1973
#Joseph C. Ragusa, 1973
*Harry B. Zimmerman, 1973
Donald G. Fraser, 1974
#Karl H. Schaefer, 1974
David E. Price, 1975
#Frank M. Walter, 1975
Robert W. Anstey, 1976
James E. Hogan, 1977
Samuel G. Walls, 1978
Robert N. Bonsall, 1979
E. Leo Dampman, 1980
Robert C. Beven, 1981
John A. Boyd, 1983
Wayne C. Anglero, 1984
Craig J. Johnston, 1985
Charles J. Sampson, 1986
Dale F. Kressley, 1987
Noni D. Cui, 1992, 1999, 2000
Bruce L. Hewlett, 1993
Abraham B. Medina, 1994
*William H. Hubbard, 2001
G. Douglas Rickards, 2006, 2007
Dean Spangler, 2008, 2009, 2010
# affiliated from merger with Newlight Lodge
* affiliated from another lodge